oriental despotism

A concept popularized by the German sociologist Karl Wittfogel, a member of the Frankfurt School of critical theory who fled the Third Reich in 1933, and spent much of the rest of his academic career in the United States (see his Oriental Despotism, 1957). Wittfogel, an expert on Chinese civilization, was a controversial figure who seems, during the course of a colourful career, to have traversed the political spectrum from Stalinism to McCarthyism. His fame rests largely on the dispute engendered by his concept of oriental despotism and his analysis of the so-called ‘hydraulic society’.
In his early work, Wittfogel described China as having experienced feudalism , on the grounds that the Chou state was based on the collection by ruling clans of tithes, in the form of communal labour by peasants working on public fields. Subsequently, a transition from labour-rent to rent-in-kind and money-rent implies that the feudal relation between the peasant communities and local lords gave way to ‘oriental despotism’, in which the primary mode of extracting surplus value from direct producers became money-rent paid to the centralized state . Although Wittfogel is by no means clear about the sequence of events (in his later work Chou China is reclassified as an instance of oriental despotism), he argues that the transition between the two modes of production was prompted mainly by the expansion and intensification of agriculture by means of large-scale irrigation, control of which necessitated co-ordination by a centralized state. This is the so-called ‘hydraulic hypothesis’, which states that irrigation is a major cause of the emergence of centralized political authority, and is thus a significant force in the development of early civilizations. Oriental Despotism considers this thesis in relation, not only to China, but also wider Marxist arguments about the Asiatic mode of production .
Wittfogel's work has been criticized as empirically unsound, inconsistent, ecologically determinist , and implicitly functionalist. However, his characterization of the agrarian state bureaucracy of early hydraulic societies prompted an enormous literature on state formation and class relationships in South-east Asia, and he has also been described as a sophisticated multilinear evolutionist.

Dictionary of sociology. 2013.

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Oriental despotism — is a term used to describe a despotic form of government that opposes the western tradition. Historically, the term s meaning has varied and today it is hardly ever used at all, largely because of all the issues surrounding the concept of… …   Wikipedia

  • Oriental studies — Ancient Assyrian antiquities in the British Museum. In the 19th century the placing of spectacular antiquities in the new museums brought unusual interest from the gene …   Wikipedia

  • ВОСТОЧНЫЙ ДЕСПОТИЗМ — (oriental despotism) ныне в значительной степени дискредитированный термин Карла Виттфогеля (1955) для азиатского общества (см. Азиатский способ производства и азиатское общество) и подобных типов социальной системы. Азиатское общество форма,… …   Большой толковый социологический словарь

  • ВОСТОЧНЫЙ ДЕСПОТИЗМ — (ORIENTAL DESPOTISM) Начало современной дискуссии о деспотизме восходит к французской общественной мысли XVIII в. Ш. Монтескье (Montesquieu, 1748) делил политические системы на республики, монархии и деспотии на основании присущих им… …   Социологический словарь

  • Karl August Wittfogel — (1896 1988) fue un dramaturgo, historiador y sinólogo germano estadounidense. Originalmente marxista y miembro activo del Partido Comunista de Alemania, después de la Segunda Guerra Mundial Wittfogel fue un feroz anticomunista. Contenido 1… …   Wikipedia Español

  • Byzantine Literature — • The four cultural elements included are the Greek, the Christian, the Roman, and the Oriental Catholic Encyclopedia. Kevin Knight. 2006. Byzantine Literature     Byzantine Literature …   Catholic encyclopedia

  • Tsarist autocracy — The Tsarist autocracy[a] (Russian: царское самодержавие, transcr. tsarskoye samoderzhaviye) refers to a form of autocracy (later, absolute monarchy) specific to the Grand Duchy of Muscovy (which later became Tsardom of Russia and the Russian… …   Wikipedia

  • India — /in dee euh/, n. 1. Hindi, Bharat. a republic in S Asia: a union comprising 25 states and 7 union territories; formerly a British colony; gained independence Aug. 15, 1947; became a republic within the Commonwealth of Nations Jan. 26, 1950.… …   Universalium

  • Hydraulic empire — A hydraulic empire, also known as a hydraulic despotism or water monopoly empire , is a social or government structure which maintains power and control through exclusive control over access to water. It arises through the need for flood control… …   Wikipedia

  • Chinese historiography — History of China ANCIENT …   Wikipedia

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”

We are using cookies for the best presentation of our site. Continuing to use this site, you agree with this.